In both the testimony of FBI Agent Fife, and FBI Agent Hurly, we heard how very important and potentially exculpatory evidence was destroyed and/or excluded from their investigation.  The government failed to properly secure the gun and all of its parts, the crime scene, and the partial fingerprints pulled from the weapon. Despite the clear import of this case (as evidenced by President Karazi’s involvement), FBI Agent Hurley told us that the investigation did not even begin until one week had passed.  Moreover, the investigation itself was anything but unbiased.  Those directly involved in the shooting of Dr. Siddiqui were responsible for guiding the investigation of the crime scene.

With respect to the metal detectors and identity screening taking place at the trial, this is just one of the numerous steps that the government has taken to create an environment of fear and intimidation.  Not only do the metal detectors and identity screening unfairly prejudice the jury, they are also a violation of Dr. Aafia Siddiqui’s right to a fair and open trial and discourage certain segments of the public from attending the proceedings.  Again, this is a trial for simple attempted assault.  Dr. Siddiqui has not been charged with any crime relating to terrorism.


Tina Monshipour Foster

Executive Director

International Justice Network